Tiktok's Triumph and Tribulations: Unravelling Nepal's Ban

Tiktok, first released in September 2016 in China, has been the most popular website of 2021—vanquishing even Google, just three years after its global unleashing. Tiktok is a China-based short video—ranging from 3 seconds to 10 minutes—hosting company that records more than 2 billion mobile downloads, with over 1.6 billion users globally. No wonder that the long prevailing social and info-tech brands must have been traumatized at the shortcut of this success. And yes, it may well have fomented the influential countries who are the pioneers in showcasing such internet products, most particularly the United States among others, to stymie it from growing further. Donald Trump, while being the president, announced the Tiktok ban in the USA in 2020, which, after nearly 3 years later, now under Biden’s presidency, led to its CEO testifying in front of congressmen and establishment of separate operations in the US. Now almost 70% of the US states have already restricted federal and state employees on the use of Tiktok on government devices. Britain and New Zealand have also imposed similar bans in the recent past. Lately, Montana has been the first state to ban Tiktok completely much like what Nepal has decided now. India, meanwhile, also banned Tiktok in 2020, alluding to the loose end of possible data usage by the company, closely rein​ed in by the Chinese government.

While the US and its allies, quite understandably, might challenge all forms of Chinese supremacy, internet brands not excluded, as we have been observing their protractedly smoldering economic rivalry and geopolitical power play. It is a big game of countries in contest to be the global commander, not only a tit-for-tat strategy against China which has forbidden many foreign internet websites from the time unmemorable. But, the Tiktok ban in Nepal has nothing to give and take with the wider geopolitical game. 

The ‘tap tap’ culture brought home the b​roader repercussions. Having known that internet penetration of Nepal has surpassed half of the population, it is not difficult to conjecture that the same number of people are exposed to the Tiktok content directly or else. There are thousands of Nepali Tiktok influencers who capitalize this platform to get millions of engagements with not-so-thought-provoking and not-so-knowledge-offering online streaming. Followers, in turn, might get enchanted to send online gifts that may have cost them monthslong sweating blood. That said, it is not to say there is nobody with good content and commendable output.

Also, the Tiktok algorithm is so dehumanizing our youths that they have become literally the living zombies—walking absent-mindedly. It takes only a video or two and you start to fall in a never-ending crevasse. Yes, every full video you watch or repeat is digging a digital crevasse deeper to fit you in among your favorites. An invisible wall is gradually built around a definitive bubble of your liking and you won’t bother to realize because it is offering a customized entertainment package that a youth seeks in his adolescence. Therefore, addiction is bound to ensue and there are overarching issues of declining attention span among children due to prolonged use.  

Tiktok has also produced numerous so-called gurus, pundits and specialists with their gripping over-exaggerated contents. Instead of scrutinizing the contents and fact-checking for their authenticity, Nepali audiences, most quite new to the internet world with a dearth of cyber awareness, tend to engulf them categorically. So, those pundits are weaponizing Tiktok to produce their believers and hardliners. Undoubtedly, Tiktok has yielded a semi-literate medical consultant in every home who advises you how to cure diabetes, a high-school dietician who indoctrinates you how to fast effectively and a pompous astrologer who used to be a mason but now predicts your future. The genuine professionals, unfortunately, have disappeared in the online crowd of sensational facsimiles. Haven't these short videos really washed away the nuances of professional capacities? And will they not eventually jeopardize the delicate balance between the social integrities as such?     

The youth users quite clearly exploit visual sexualization and spoken vulgarity in the avarice of being viral. This makes opening Tiktok around family members unsuitable in the dread of ending with a salubriously shouting pop-up. Further, children might be exposed to the improper Tiktok contents owing to the leeway to access their guardians’ mobile anytime. There have been a lot of examples of people becoming online celebrities overnight, failing to keep up the fame and then living in the misery of depression, let alone the examples of people falling off-cliff and dying while absorbed to make a Tiktok video.

Tiktok is also a contrivance to promote one’s business and advise travel plans and destinations. Out of 2.2 million active Nepali Tiktok users, the majority of them are also inclined to use Tiktok for market research as well as for making decisions to purchase the products. Admittedly, Tiktok has been a boon to those with real talents, but at what stakes should we tender our thumbs up for merely a few reasons that are good? The obvious aftermath of this ban might be grouping up of the Tiktok influencers, lawyers and activists, filing cases in the court on account of undermining the constitutional rights of freedom of speech, access to information and media independence but truth be told: if government has a proper justification of a ban then it prevails as bigger democracies in the neighborhood, Europe and parts of Africa are still sustaining such bans.   

Banning internet products is never a solution unless the people are not self-conscientious and judicious. Tiktok should have been already closely surveiled as there were overt cases of users being imposter, creating obscene materials, disinforming public for vested interests and promoting the culture of foul-mouthing and hatred. And this is not unequally applicable to Facebook, Instagram, YouTube and the like. In a country like ours when parliamentary discussion about e-commerce is ongoing, MPs proudly boast upon their views on selling electricity being bamboozled on the bill titled ‘vidyutiya karobar ain’, we can’t expect a good nuanced policy that forbids the misuse of platform and promotes its use for the greater good. We have been accustomed to black or white policy, if it works, ‘allow’; and if it doesn’t, 'ban'. Our administration is never enthusiastic—if capable at all, in doing thorough homework before flinging orders and decisions. This time it has failed in diving into the platform and sorting out the bad from the rest of the content to punish the creator or restrict troubling content.

The blanket ban—which is, of course, arbitrary and not thoughtful—might have come from the political leaders being involved in scandal after scandal and more so after alleged propagation of social disharmony and casteism. A new directive on the operation of social networking is in place; hence, ​the document must be serving as something called impetus to formulate laws regarding social media regulation lest other platforms be similarly banned. Otherwise, how can features of other apps like Facebook or Instagram reels, YouTube Shorts be spared that bear pretty much similar algorithms and contents? If the MPs maneuver their consolidated efforts on forming robust rules, who knows Tiktok would be revitalized to open access—with certain qualifications—much like Pakistan which revoked the ban in no less than two weeks? It is unequivocal that the coming days are sure to be filled with an environment more dependent on internet products, so, it is better to draft the act and implement right away so that it can further be polished on a need-basis.

 A paraphrased version of this article can be found in print of 'The Annapurna Express" weekly English news magazine dated 30th November 2023. Click here for the online version of that article.

Case of Tiktok Ban in Nepal

Nepal government banned Tiktok on 13 November, Monday after a cabinet meeting. 

Post a Comment

0 Comments